diff --git a/doorrando/hudadditions.asm b/doorrando/hudadditions.asm
index 9fa293a..1c0bc1f 100644
--- a/doorrando/hudadditions.asm
+++ b/doorrando/hudadditions.asm
@@ -80,10 +80,10 @@ DRHUD_DrawKeyCounter:
 .dungeon_id
 	TAX
 	LDA.l GenericKeys : LSR : BCS .total_only
-	LDA.w DungeonAllCollectedKeys-1, X : JSR ConvertToDisplay : STA.w HUDKeysObtained
+	LDA.w DungeonCollectedKeys, X : JSR ConvertToDisplay : STA.w HUDKeysObtained
 	LDA.w #!SlashTile : STA.w HUDKeysSlash
 .total_only
-	LDA.l TotalKeys, x : JSR ConvertToDisplay : STA.w HUDKeysTotal
+	LDA.l ChestKeys, x : JSR ConvertToDisplay : STA.w HUDKeysTotal
 	JMP DRHUD_Finished
 
 OWRHUD_DrawWorldIndicator:
@@ -264,9 +264,13 @@ ConvertToDisplay2:
     ++ lda.w #$2827 : rts ; 0/O for 0 or placeholder digit ;2483
 
 CountAbsorbedKeys:
+	JML IncrementSmallKeysNoPrimary
+
+; This function apporach doesn't currently work
+CountAbsorbedKeysViaCountAllKey:
 	PHA : PHX
 	LDA.l StandingItemsOn : BEQ .count_it
-	LDA.w SpawnedItemKeyCounted : BNE .done
+;	LDA.w SpawnedItemKeyCounted : BNE .done ; this was added because pot keys were being double counted when they weren't shuffled
 	CPY.b #$24 : BEQ .count_it ; small key for this dungeon
 	LDA.w DungeonID : LSR : TAX
 	TYA : CMP.l KeyTable, X : BNE .done
@@ -276,7 +280,7 @@ CountAbsorbedKeys:
 	REP #$10 : JSL CountAllKey : SEP #$10
 	LDY.b Scrap02
 .done
-	STZ.w SpawnedItemKeyCounted ; reset to zero for next time
+;	STZ.w SpawnedItemKeyCounted ; reset to zero for next time
 	PLX : PLA
 	JML IncrementSmallKeysNoPrimary
 
diff --git a/inventory.asm b/inventory.asm
index 8167fe7..97de1a5 100644
--- a/inventory.asm
+++ b/inventory.asm
@@ -220,7 +220,7 @@ DungeonIncrement:
    REP #$10
    PHX
    LDA.w InventoryTable_properties,X : BIT.b #$40 : BEQ +
-   		JSL CountAllKey
+   		JSL CountChestKeyLong
    +
    LDA.l !MULTIWORLD_RECEIVING_ITEM : BNE .done
 	SEP #$10
diff --git a/keydrop/standing_items.asm b/keydrop/standing_items.asm
index c087e29..915b233 100644
--- a/keydrop/standing_items.asm
+++ b/keydrop/standing_items.asm
@@ -697,7 +697,6 @@ KeyGet:
             LDA.b Scrap00 : CMP.l KeyTable, X : BNE +
                 .countIt
                 LDA.l StandingItemCounterMask : AND SpawnedItemFlag : BEQ ++
-										STA.w SpawnedItemKeyCounted
                     JSL AddInventory
                 ++ PLX : PLA : RTL
             + CMP.b #$AF : beq .countIt ; universal key
diff --git a/ram.asm b/ram.asm
index 4ad5b70..cc98bdc 100644
--- a/ram.asm
+++ b/ram.asm
@@ -330,7 +330,6 @@ SpawnedItemFlag = $7E0726         ; 0x02 - one for pot, 2 for sprite drop
 SpawnedItemMWPlayer = $7E0728     ; Player Id for spawned item if Multiworld item 0x02
                                   ;
 EnemyDropIndicator = $7E072A      ; Used by HUD to indicate enemy drops remaining
-SpawnedItemKeyCounted = $7E072C   ; If set, the spawned item has been counted towards dungeon key total
 SkipBeeTrapDisguise = $7E072D     ; Flag to skip bee trap disguise during draw routine
 
 SprDropsItem = $7E0730            ; Array for whether a sprite drops an item 0x16
@@ -915,7 +914,6 @@ endmacro
 %assertRAM(SpawnedItemFlag, $7E0726)
 %assertRAM(SpawnedItemMWPlayer, $7E0728)
 %assertRAM(EnemyDropIndicator, $7E072A)
-%assertRAM(SpawnedItemKeyCounted, $7E072C)
 %assertRAM(SkipBeeTrapDisguise, $7E072D)
 %assertRAM(SprDropsItem, $7E0730)
 %assertRAM(SprItemReceipt, $7E0740)
diff --git a/stats.asm b/stats.asm
index 6adca40..492b6de 100644
--- a/stats.asm
+++ b/stats.asm
@@ -118,7 +118,41 @@ RTL
 
 ;--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
+CountChestKeyLong:
+	PHX : PHP
+	SEP #$30
+	JSR CountChestKey
+	PLP : PLX
+	RTL
+;--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+CountChestKey:
+	PHA : PHX
+  LDA.l !MULTIWORLD_ITEM_PLAYER_ID : BNE .done
+  LDA.l StatsLocked : BNE .done
+  CPY.b #$24 : BEQ .this_dungeon
+	TYA
+	AND.b #$0F : CMP.b #$02 : BCC .hc_sewers
+	TAX
+	LDA.l DungeonCollectedKeys,X : INC : STA.l DungeonCollectedKeys,X
+	BRA .done
+
+.this_dungeon
+	LDA.w DungeonID : CMP.b #$03 : BCC .hc_sewers
+	LSR : TAX
+	LDA.l DungeonCollectedKeys,X : INC : STA.l DungeonCollectedKeys,X
+	BRA .done
+
+.hc_sewers
+	LDA.l SewerCollectedKeys : INC
+	STA.l SewerCollectedKeys : STA.l HCCollectedKeys
+
+.done
+	PLX : PLA
+	RTS
+
 ; Expects 16 bit index mode upon entering. 8-bit Acumulator
+; This approach doesn't currently work - potentially dead code
 CountAllKey:
   PHP : PHA : PHX
 	SEP #$10