diff --git a/Rules.py b/Rules.py
index 07c7e6af..a7941814 100644
--- a/Rules.py
+++ b/Rules.py
@@ -2111,7 +2111,7 @@ def eval_small_key_door_main(state, door_name, dungeon, player):
         elif ruleType == KeyRuleType.AllowSmall:
             if (door_rule.small_location.item and door_rule.small_location.item.name == key_logic.small_key_name
                and door_rule.small_location.item.player == player):
-                return True  # always okay if allow small is on
+                door_openable |= state.has_sm_key(key_logic.small_key_name, player, number)
         elif isinstance(ruleType, tuple):
             lock, lock_item = ruleType
             # this doesn't track logical locks yet, i.e. hammer locks the item and hammer is there, but the item isn't