diff --git a/source/classes/CustomSettings.py b/source/classes/CustomSettings.py
index 0145c319..2a8a39f6 100644
--- a/source/classes/CustomSettings.py
+++ b/source/classes/CustomSettings.py
@@ -59,6 +59,7 @@ class CustomSettings(object):
                 if isinstance(player_setting, str):
                     weights = get_weights(os.path.join(self.relative_dir, player_setting))
                     settings = defaultdict(lambda: None, vars(roll_settings(weights)))
+                    args.mystery = True
                 else:
                     settings = defaultdict(lambda: None, player_setting)
                 args.shuffle[p] = get_setting(settings['shuffle'], args.shuffle[p])
diff --git a/source/tools/MysteryUtils.py b/source/tools/MysteryUtils.py
index 51c6c153..3fbbbf8d 100644
--- a/source/tools/MysteryUtils.py
+++ b/source/tools/MysteryUtils.py
@@ -46,7 +46,6 @@ def roll_settings(weights):
     ret = argparse.Namespace()
 
     ret.algorithm = get_choice('algorithm')
-    ret.mystery = get_choice_default('mystery', default=True)
 
     glitch_map = {'none': 'noglitches', 'no_logic': 'nologic', 'owglitches': 'owglitches',
                   'owg': 'owglitches', 'minorglitches': 'minorglitches'}